The Town of Bay Harbor Islands changed two prices on the Broad Causeway this fall, two months apart. On October 1, 2026, the annual pass plan for town residents dropped to $200. On December 1, 2026, the two-axle toll goes up to $3.25 with SunPass and $6.50 by Toll-By-Plate.
Each change makes the pass a better deal. Combined, they move the break-even point to a little more than one crossing a week. For most households, the more important thing to get right is the condition the pass carries.
From December, the break-even drops from 175 crossings to about 62
Before October, the town's annual pass cost $350 and anyone could buy it, with no residency requirement. A six-month version cost $225, according to an August 19, 2026 staff report prepared for the September 10 Town Council meeting. The agenda for that meeting included an item to cut the resident price from $350 to $200 a year. On September 29, the Town posted an alert confirming the $200 resident plan and a new toll schedule.
The per-crossing toll has been flat for two years. The Town's current rate sheet sets the two-axle toll at $2.00 with SunPass and $3.25 by plate, effective October 1, 2024.
Divide the price of the pass by the per-crossing toll and you get the number of crossings that cover it:
| Pass price | SunPass toll | Crossings to break even | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resident before October 1, 2026 | $350 | $2.00 | 175 |
| Resident, October 1 to November 30, 2026 | $200 | $2.00 | 100 |
| Resident from December 1, 2026 | $200 | $3.25 | about 62 |
| Nonresident annual from December 1, 2026 | $350 | $3.25 | about 108 |
Under the old pricing, a resident needed about three and a half crossings a week before the pass paid for itself. Until November 30, it takes about two. From December 1, it takes about 1.2. From 175 crossings to 62 is a 65 percent drop in the threshold. The resident price fell 43 percent and the SunPass toll is rising 62.5 percent, so the two changes compound. The 62.5 percent figure comes from the Town's own staff memo.
The table counts each trip through the toll as one crossing. The Town's 2026 notices list rates but don't say whether the toll is charged in both directions, so your own count should be based on how many times your car actually passes the plaza in a year. If you buy the pass this week, the first five weeks of the one-year term are still at the $2.00 rate, and the higher rate applies to the remaining eleven months.
What a week of driving costs after December 1
The same math works as an annual bill. These figures use the December 1 two-axle rates:
| Crossings per week | Yearly crossings | SunPass, paying per crossing | Toll-By-Plate | Resident pass | Nonresident pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 52 | $169 | $338 | $200 | $350 |
| 2 | 104 | $338 | $676 | $200 | $350 |
| 3 | 156 | $507 | $1,014 | $200 | $350 |
| 5 | 260 | $845 | $1,690 | $200 | $350 |
At one crossing a week, paying per crossing with SunPass still costs less than the resident pass. At two crossings a week, the pass saves $138 over the year, and the gap grows from there. The Toll-By-Plate column is the highest cost on the chart, and the plate rate also rises more sharply. It goes from $3.25 to $6.50, which doubles it, while SunPass goes up by $1.25.
The pass works only through one transponder in one car
The plan is a prepaid subscription, and the transponder is the only thing that exempts you from the toll. Under the 2026-2027 pass plan application, each pass covers one transponder in one vehicle for the length of the term. The application's terms state:
"The SunPass transponder registered to your pass plan is the sole means by which you may pass through the toll without being charged... The pass plan does not allow for no-cost trips using your license plate and you may not seek reimbursement for that which is not covered under the pass plan."
The application also says that if the transponder isn't read, the resulting image toll or Toll-By-Plate charge is yours to pay "regardless of the reason." Starting December 1, the Toll-By-Plate charge is $6.50 per crossing. That applies whenever a transponder is moved to another car, mounted badly, or left at home.
A two-car household needs a separate pass for each car. The $200 resident plan is limited to two-axle, non-commercial vehicles. Visitors with an E-ZPass or another compatible transponder pay the lower electronic rate, according to the Town's rate sheet. That sheet also warns that a car carrying both an out-of-state transponder and a SunPass will probably be charged twice. A guest with no transponder at all is billed by plate. Crossing twice a day for a week at the December plate rate comes to $91, more than half the price of a resident pass.
Applying takes three documents with the same address
The resident plan isn't automatic. According to the Town's October 1 alert, the process works like this:
- Answer yes to the "I am a resident" question on the online application.
- Upload your driver's license, vehicle registration and a utility bill, all showing the same address.
- Wait for approval, which comes by email with a link to pay.
The matching-address requirement is the step most likely to slow you down. Your utility bill, license and registration all need to show the same Bay Harbor Islands address. If your car is registered somewhere else, or the utility account is in another household member's name, the three documents may not match, and the application can't be approved until they do.
Bal Harbour and Surfside neighbors still pay the $350 rate
The $200 price is for Bay Harbor Islands residents. Everyone else, including the many Bal Harbour and Surfside residents who use the causeway to reach the mainland, still pays $350 for 365 days or $225 for six months. At the December rate, the annual nonresident pass breaks even at about 108 crossings. The six-month pass breaks even at about 70 crossings over its term, which works out to a little under three a week.
Council looked at wider eligibility. The staff report for the September 10 meeting laid out three options:
- Option 1 offered $200 a year or $150 for six months to Bay Harbor Islands residents. It offered $350 or $225 to property owners, town employees, school families, and residents of designated nearby areas, a list that named Bal Harbour, Indian Creek Village, Surfside, San Souci and Keystone Point.
- Option 2 limited the plan to vehicles registered in Bay Harbor Islands, at $200 or $150.
- Option 3 set a standard price of $350 or $225 for all buyers, with rebates for town residents that brought their cost to $200 or $150. It depended on reciprocal agreements with nearby communities.
The plan the Town actually announced is the $200 one-year resident price. Nonresidents still pay the standard $350 and $225 rates. For now, if you live across the town line in Bal Harbour, you pay $150 more a year than a resident of Bay Harbor Islands for the same pass. Any later change to the program would be decided by the Council, and its agendas are posted on the Town's CivicClerk portal.
Why the toll went up, and the bridge behind it
The staff memo on the increase says the Council asked for a bigger jump than the usual yearly increments and for higher charges on heavier vehicles because of wear. Staff recommended matching Miami-Dade's two-axle base rates and keeping the Town's own steps for vehicles with more axles. Those steps are steep. A three-axle vehicle goes to $10.25 with SunPass and $15.00 by plate, and each axle beyond five adds $7.00 with SunPass or $8.50 by plate. Contractor trucks and moving vans pay those rates too.
The draft resolution gives increased revenue and the causeway's long-term financial sustainability as its goals. The bridge needs a lot of work. The April 22, 2026 Council agenda included ratifying a second emergency repair contract with Florida Draw Bridges Inc. for $670,879.26, plus $253,880 for construction-engineering inspection. The September agenda added a third proposal from the same contractor. It would cost $213,084 to install steel plates over what the agenda calls "severely deteriorated header joints" on the Intracoastal bridge. In the August 2026 town newsletter, the town manager reported that the pier cap and pedestal repairs were finished and that work on the expansion joints was underway.
The longer-term plan is a new bridge. According to AtkinsRéalis, the Town started the replacement process in August 2022 and hired the firm for planning, environmental studies, design and construction engineering. A November 2024 Town report put the full project at $257,101,605.16, with Town toll revenue as part of the proposed local share. The September 10, 2026 agenda included a vote on final rankings for the replacement bridge's design consultant. That vote picks a designer. It doesn't start construction.
So for now, Bay Harbor Islands drivers will keep crossing a 2026 repair job and paying 2026 rates while the replacement is designed. Everything in this post is general information drawn from the Town's published notices, not legal or financial advice. Confirm your own eligibility and terms on the Town's toll information page before you apply.
Running the toll math is the same kind of analysis I do for clients weighing a move between Bay Harbor Islands, Bal Harbour and Surfside, where costs like this one show up every week. If you'd like that comparison done for your own routes and addresses, Jennifer Brilliant can work through the numbers with you. Let's Connect.